It promises to be a decisive day for South Africa’s governing coalition. This Sunday, 15 November, the African National Congress (ANC) and the Democratic Alliance (DA) begin coalition negotiations under a heavy cloud. The talks were triggered by the 4 November municipal elections, which left nearly a hundred councils without an outright majority, including major Gauteng metros such as Johannesburg, Tshwane and Ekurhuleni. Yet the stakes go far beyond local government: the future of the government of national unity, formed in 2024, is quietly on the line.
The backdrop could hardly be worse for Nelson Mandela’s party. With 30.76% of the vote, the ANC recorded the worst result in its history, down almost 15 points from the 2021 municipal elections. The DA rose to 24.64%, ahead of Jacob Zuma’s MK party, the EFF and ActionSA. The ANC lost its outright majority in more than a hundred municipalities it previously controlled. For its main partner, by contrast, the vote marked progress: DA leader Geordin Hill-Lewis said his party had taken « a big step forward ».
Within the ANC, the defeat has revived an old debate. At the meeting of the national executive committee (NEC) in Boksburg on Thursday, a majority of speakers called for the government of national unity to be reviewed in its current form, according to party insiders quoted by the Sunday Times. Many blame the alliance with the DA for part of the party’s electoral collapse, accusing it of alienating the ANC’s base. Cyril Ramaphosa himself reportedly vented his frustration to NEC members, saying he was « tired » of a partner that constantly second-guesses the ANC’s policies and drags it to court.
Relations between the head of state and Geordin Hill-Lewis have also soured. According to Business Day, ANC insiders accuse the DA leadership of trying to bypass Luthuli House, the party’s headquarters, by favouring direct lines to the presidency. The two parties have already clashed in court, and after a ruling in the ANC’s favour, secretary-general Fikile Mbalula publicly questioned whether the DA still adhered to the coalition’s founding principles.
Several scenarios are now on the table. The ANC’s negotiating team has four options, ranging from a « local government of unity » across the eight metros to confidence-and-supply agreements or alliances that exclude the DA. ActionSA, the party of former Johannesburg mayor Herman Mashaba, is repeatedly mentioned as an alternative partner, at both municipal and national level. Officially, however, the NEC opted for « tactical flexibility », meaning talks with all parties without ruling out the DA from the outset, even though IOL reports the DA will be treated as a last resort in municipal negotiations.
The DA, for its part, is projecting calm. Its federal council chair, Ashor Sarupen, insists the party is negotiating in good faith, on shared service-delivery principles rather than through horse-trading. A breakup would nonetheless have consequences far beyond municipal councils. The DA is seen as the driving force behind business-friendly reforms within the government, and a reshaped coalition could unsettle investors.
The first answers will come from the metros. The inaugural council sittings in Johannesburg and Tshwane, where new mayors are to be elected, will serve as a test. Their outcome will show whether the ANC and the DA can still govern together, or whether South Africa is heading towards a new political configuration ahead of the ANC’s elective conference in December 2027, when Cyril Ramaphosa is due to step down as party leader, and the 2029 general elections.