Skip to content
 
Politics

Zimbabwe: Constitutional Court weighs Mnangagwa’s extended term

In Harare, the fate of the country's most contested reform now rests in the hands of the Constitutional Court judges. Outside, war veterans turned away by police were left waiting for a ruling that will not come any time soon.

Zimbabwe: Constitutional Court weighs Mnangagwa’s extended term

The decision will have to wait. On Wednesday, November 18, Zimbabwe’s Constitutional Court reserved judgment in two challenges to Constitutional Amendment No. 3, which Emmerson Mnangagwa signed into law on July 7. No date has been announced for the ruling. The contested law lengthens presidential and parliamentary terms from five to seven years, pushes the next general elections from 2028 to 2030 and scraps the direct election of the head of state, handing that choice to Parliament.

The first challenge, brought by Vhurande Mahlupeko, goes after the way the law was made. About ten provisions, including those expanding the Constitutional Court, were allegedly added to the bill without ever being published in the Government Gazette or put to the public consultation the Constitution requires. The applicant is not asking for a simple cleanup: he wants the entire law struck down, arguing that MPs may well have voted for the text precisely because of the disputed clauses.

The second case, brought by former opposition MP Prince Dubeko Sibanda, takes aim at the reform’s beneficiaries. It rests on Section 328(7) of the Constitution, which bars any change extending a term of office from benefiting those who hold that office when the change is adopted. Yet the amendment applies precisely to the sitting president and the lawmakers who passed it. The applicants also raised a conflict of interest, arguing that the head of state should not have signed a law from which he draws such an obvious personal benefit.

The State, for its part, defended the procedure. The added provisions, it said, were covered by a memorandum that allowed Parliament to consider governance matters beyond the original proposals. The government mainly disputed the Court’s jurisdiction to hear Prince Dubeko Sibanda’s application as a court of first instance. Parliament did not deny that Section 328 contains those safeguards, but argued that wording placed at the head of the transitional clauses, introduced by the word “notwithstanding”, was enough to override them.

Constitutional lawyer Lovemore Madhuku, who represents both applicants, said the judges asked many questions about how the disputed provisions had been inserted. He declined to predict the outcome, while saying he was confident he had put forward a strong case.

The atmosphere around the court spoke volumes about how sensitive the case is. A heavy security presence surrounded the building in Harare. Dozens of liberation war veterans who had come to follow the hearing were blocked by police, and journalists were denied entry to the courtroom. The image carries weight in a country where veterans long served as a pillar of the ruling establishment and now rank among the reform’s most determined opponents.

These two cases are only part of a wider legal battle. In September, the Court reserved judgment on a bid by a group of war veterans contesting the end of direct presidential elections without a referendum, and in early November it did the same with another challenge based on citizens’ right to choose their president. On November 25, Douglas Mwonzora’s Movement for Democratic Change will argue that the head of state failed in his duty to call a referendum.

The stakes go beyond Emmerson Mnangagwa himself. He came to power in November 2017 after the fall of Robert Mugabe, was elected in 2018 and re-elected in 2023, and could not seek another term under the 2013 Constitution, which limits the presidency to two terms. In ruling, the judges will decide how far a Parliament may reshape a constitutional amendment bill after its publication, and whether the safeguards written thirteen years ago can hold against the will of those they were meant to restrain.

TAMN

The African Meridian Newsroom

Reporting by the newsroom of The African Meridian, an independent Pan-African news publication.